The Last Time I Saw Richard (2014) Reviews

• Interesting but almost too much going on for even a longer short film

  bob the moo2015-04-01

  This short film runs to 22 minutes, which doesn't sound like much, but is quite an ask when I'd say the majority of short films would tend to be around the 8-10 minute mark. With longer short films, you can find that the runtime is excessive and maybe the same could have been done in less time however with this film it actually cuts the other way because 20 something minutes really isn't enough for how much is in here. The story is set in a mental health clinic for troubled teens, and here is where we find self-harmer Jonah, who greatly enjoys his role as aggressive loner of the clinic. When he is forced to share a room with new boy Richard, he is resistant, however a shared understanding of each other's struggles brings about the seeds of a sort of friendship. The nature of this relationships brings in a sense of vulnerability to Richard, a question over the sexuality of the two boys, and a series of reasonably disturbing scenes where the boys' emotional demons are given a very literal on-screen translation. The style of delivery is quite clipped and defensive, which makes it a little hard to watch at first, but grew on me as an approach because it felt realistic to the characters and material. These barriers never totally fall, but small things give insight and give some thoughts about the relationship which go beyond the stuff we expressly see. All of it I found quite engaging, but there is an ironic problem here – which is that it almost tries to do too much. I am not sure if this is a pitch at a feature, but there are almost too many ideas and as a result everything feels like it could (should?) have gone further, or had more detail put into it. This applies to the individuals, their situations, the clinic, the demons, the nature of the boys' relationship (or at least Jonah's side of it), and several other aspects which are present but could have been more. Hopefully this does mean that the plan is to make this a feature, because it offers horror elements but with the chance for some well observed character aspects too. In that regard, the cast probably would not carry over to a feature – they are good enough for the material, but don't really deliver; perhaps this is a knock-on effect of the film trying to give them so much to do, but while I did like Wallace in the main role, I didn't think Fern had as much chance to make an impression. The Last Time I saw Richard is an interesting film that, while longer than average, probably suffers from having too many good ideas, meaning that almost all aspects has room to have done more or to have greater detail to get into. I tend to like my short films just to remain short films, but this is one of the cases where I would love to see what more time and resources could do with such an interesting short as its base.

• Woah, what a thrilling short!

  Irishchatter2018-09-02

  I honestly thought that this was going to be a sweet gay short since both boys were really fond of each other and that they were inseparable! However there was so much going on in Jonah's head that it really was mindblowing of what his mental illness is involving. I'm guessing both boys have schizophrenia but the short doesn't really say much of what their diagnosis' are. Well done to all involved, including Toby Wallace and Cody Fern for their fantastic performances as the lads! :)

• Excellent

  jttholden2019-02-12

  Tightly constructed little chiller, highlighted by clean direction, atmospheric cinematography, crisp sound, and exceptional film editing. Toby Wallace and Cody Fern give compelling and moving performances as disturbed teens who may need each other more than either of them knows upon first meeting. The Last Time I Saw Richard is a textbook example of how to make a short film. Free of gimmicks and surefooted from start to finish. Students of film, take note. This is how to do it.

• Not too captivating

  Horst_In_Translation2016-04-01

  "The Last Time I Saw Richard" is an Australian (undeservingly) award-winning 25-minute live action short film from 2 years ago. The writer and director here is Nicholas Verso. What I found the most disappointing is how long he has been making films already and still, this is a really mediocre outcome. None of the aspects from this film stays in the mind. It is very much style over substance, tries to be shocking and matter on several occasions, but it always feels like try-hard and never as if I was watching a great story. The limited capability of the two lead actors is also not helping things. Even at under 30 minutes, this film dragged on a couple occasions. I do not recommend watching this one and I hope everybody involved with this one here can step up their game in the next years. They will have to if they want to make a difference. HHere they do not.